Buy The Pie

  • Whole pies come in 14″ and 18″.

  • Substitute 14″ Gluten Free Crust +$2.00.

  • Substitute Follow Your Heart Vegan Cheese Add $2.00 / $2.50

  • Build your own

    Whole milk mozzarella + additional toppings

    $17 / $22

  • Cheese

    Whole milk mozzarella cheese over house-made marinara red sauce

    $17 / $22

  • Pepperoni

    $20 / $24

  • Five Cheese

    Mozzarella, Cheddar, Provolone, Ricotta, Parmesan

    $21 / $26

  • Hawaiian

    Canadian Bacon, Pineapple

    $21 / $26

  • Cypress Hill

    Pepperoni, Mushroom, Olive

    $22 / $27

  • Margherita

    Fresh Garlic, Tomatoes, Basil, Fresh Mozz on Red Sauce

    $22 / $27

  • Pepperoni, Sausage, and Olive

    $23 / $29

  • Spicy Chicken

    Shredded Mozzarella, Chicken, Onion, Jalapenos, and Chopped Garlic on our House-Made Marinara Red Sauce

    $23 / $29

  • Pesto Chicken

    Chicken, Red Peppers, Olives, Fresh Basil

    $23 / $29

  • Buffalo Chicken

    Red Onion, Blue Cheese, Chicken, Franks Red Hot, Garlic + Oil Base

    $23 / $29

  • Brooklyn

    Sausage, Mushroom, Olive, Red Bell Pepper

    $23 / $29

  • Meat Lovers

    Sausage, Pepperoni, Bacon, Canadian Bacon

    $24 / $30

  • SFNY Combo

    Canadian Bacon, Pepperoni, Olives, Red Peppers, Mushrooms

    $24 / $30

  • BBQ Chicken

    Chicken, Onion, Pepperoncinis, and Shredded Parm on BBQ Base

    $23 / $29

  • Chicken Bacon Ranch

    Chicken, Bacon, Spinach, and Tomato on Ranch Sauce Base

    $24 / $30

  • Combination

    Pepperoni, Sausage, Green Peppers, Mushrooms, Olives, Onions

    $24 / $30

  • Veggie

    Red and Green Bell Peppers, Mushrooms, Olives, Onions, Artichoke Hearts on Basil Pesto Base

    $24 / $30

  • The Greek

    Spiinach, Tomato, Kalamata Olives, Red Onion, and Feta on Garlic + Oil Base

    $24 / $30

Slices

  • Cheese

    A simple, classic New York staple. Mozzarella and our tomato sauce

    $4.00

  • Pepperoni

    Our best selling slice. Pepperoni, mozzarella, tomato sauce

    $4.25

  • Vegetarian

    Mozzarella, piled high with fresh local vegetables

    $4.50

  • Chef’s Choice

    $4.50

Alternatives

  • 3 Breadsticks & Sauce

    $5.25

  • Calzone (Olive Oil, Ricotta, Mozz + 5 toppings of choice w/ one side of Red Sauce)

    $13.50

  • 6 Wings

    BBQ, Buffalo, or Plain – served with carrot and celery sticks and one side of Ranch or Blue Cheese dressing

    $7.00

  • Dozen Wings

    BBQ, Buffalo, or Plain – served with carrot and celery sticks and two sides of Ranch or Blue Cheese dressing

    $12.00

Salads

  • Caesar Salad

    Add chicken +$3.00

    $6.25

  • Garden Salad

    Add chicken +$3.00

    $6.25

  • Spinach Salad

    Add chicken +$3.00

    $6.25

  • Family Size Salad

    Choice of Caesar, Garden, or Spinach – double portion with two side dressings

    $10.50

Toppings

  • 14″ $2.50, 18″ $3.00

    Pepperoni, Sausage, Canadian Bacon, Bacon, Chicken

  • 14″ $1.50, 18″ $2.50

    Red Peppers, Green Peppers, Pepperoncinis, Onions, Pineapple, Mushrooms, Olives, Artichoke Hearts, Jalapeños, Tomatoes, Garlic, Roasted Garlic, Spinach, Basil, Kalamata Olives, Blue Cheese Crumbles, Feta, Ricotta

  • Extra Cheese $1.50/$2.00

  • Extra Sauce $0.50

Daily Specials

  • Any 2 Slices + Soda

    $9.50

  • Slice & Salad

    $9.50

  • Tallboy Special

    Cheese slice + PBR/Rainer only

    $5.00

Beverages

  • Fountain Soda

    $2.50

  • Canned Soda

    Coke, Sprite, Diet Coke, Fanta, Ginger Ale, Diet Ginger Ale

    $2.50

  • 2 Liter Soda

    Coke, Sprite, Diet Coke, Fanta

    $4.75

  • Bottled Drinks

    $3.00

  • Micro Pint

    $6.00

  • Wine

    $6.00

  • 6 Pack Micro Beer

    $14.00

  • 6 Pack Tall Boys

    $10.00

  • Growler Fill

    64oz SFNY Growler Bottle $5

    $12.00